Yes! That is exactly the scenario I had in my head!

Now I totally want to write a fic where Chad is all, "he likes me better because I've known him longest" and Jensen is all, "he likes me better because we're tv brothers and also I am awesome" and Chad's like, "I bet I can totally tap that before you do!" and Jensen is all like, "you're so on, you douche" and they're both trying to shag Jared and Jared it totally clueless and Chad and Jensen keep trying to sabotage each other and whatnot.